All The Tropes Wiki Project, Part XXXIII

[robkelk]

As long as we're setting policy... In order to protect the wiki from legal challenges, I propose that AI-generated content be specifically banned from All The Tropes.

I don’t deserve credit for noting this would be an issue because it was already a clear legal point: “AI”-generated work is not copyrightable, so if you have any “AI”-generated work in your material you open the door to legal issues. But also, the concern here is slightly different: The issue appears not to be that “AI” material isn’t copyrightable, the issue is that “AI” is trained on copyrighted material, so prose generated from it could be contested by the original copyright holders.

Now, from a practical point of view this could be a stretch to prove unless the “AI” farts out entire paragraphs of prose unaltered from its training material (which, to be clear, it can do and has done), and those end up in the finished book. But if you’re a lawyer for a publisher or a film/TV production house, even the hint of possible legal entanglement is enough to raise the shields. It’s already in contracts for both film/TV and for publishing houses that the author attests their work is wholly original, so, again, any hint that anything is other than that brings things to a screeching halt. As we have seen.

–John Scalzi , Another Reason Not to Use “AI” For Your Writing, July 31, 2026

I would like to carve out a very limited exception. AI pictures can be allowed if (A) they are explicitly identified as such, (B) they are the only relevant way to illustrate an article [i.e. they are from a work known to use AI for illustration], and (C) it can be reasonably determined said images are not a deliberate infringement on the copyright of others and/or can be considered fair use/parody.

Fair enough, as long as we identify the AI art. (We do that on the KanriKyara wiki.)